In Thursday’s Herald: Sept. 11

Tomorrow, The Herald’s Chelsea Kellner will have a feature on how teachers (high school and elementary) teach 9/11 to their students these days.
You must understand, even if it seems like yesterday to us, Sept. 11, 2001, was seven years ago. For a freshman in high school, that means they were in second grade. For a sixth-grader, they were 3 or 4 years old at the time. To them, Sept. 11, isn’t part of their memory … it’s something in their history books.

I will never fully understand the shock and fear that gripped America after the assassination of John F. Kennedy. My mom was 7 years old at the time and attending elementary school in Irving, Tx., just minutes from Dealy Plaza in Dallas, where Kennedy was killed. She remembers the day well, mostly the reactions of her teacher and parents.
I had a similar elementary school experience when our class watched the Space Shuttle Challenger blow up on live television. I, too, remember my teacher’s response (she cried) and the confusion amongst the students at the time (I was 9 years old and in the fourth grade in Atlanta, Ga., at the time).

But I was 25 and a sports writer on Sept. 11, 2001, and not only do I remember the day itself, I remember the fear even I had for the days that followed. I remember the uneasiness when I heard a plane fly overhead in the days that followed … I remember wondering if I would be drafted for a war … I remember being glued to the television in my little apartment for a week straight. I covered high school football games in the weeks that followed, and I remember the typically raucous Texas crowds were somewhat subdued … even though life was slowly moving on.

I am not sure how history teachers (many of them in college or just starting out when this happened) can explain Sept. 11 to their students. It’s one of those lessons that takes more than simply reading from a history book … there are several riveting documentaries and shows on the History Channel and Discovery Channel that give a really good depiction of the nation’s fear that day.
If I had any advice for history teachers planning on talking 9-11 tomorrow, I say talk about how it affected your life … just keep you political opinions out of it. I know a lot of people want to “spin” it one way or another, but it’s not necessary, especially for kids who don’t care about politics yet.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “In Thursday’s Herald: Sept. 11

  1. Excellent topic, and your thoughts on the experiences of those that were there and those that weren’t or were to young to really remember is well taken.

    My father watched his first color television program, which turned out to be coverage of the Kennedy assassination on the new color TV a girlfriend’s family just bought and he had been invited over to see. That must be a very odd and poignant memory for him juxtaposing the excitement of this new color wonder, and the horrible news playing out before him…. and you are right that for me, it is just ‘history’, as I wasn’t there to experience it in context.

    Should be an interesting story to watch for.

    Al

  2. I remember I was in grad school interning at Wake County Emergency Management, and was at work about to leave for the one daytime class I had, when the first plane flew into the tower. We found out about it from one of my co-worker’s friends who was watching CNN at the time. I went to class thinking it was an accident, and halfway through the class, my pager went off calling me back. It was surreal driving into Raleigh, seeing law enforcement at the corners of key intersections, and having to show my work ID at the door. Kinda funny how we didn’t have to do that in hindsight. So much has changed, but I think we can’t forget that terrorism (both domestic and international) has been a part of American history way before Al Qaeda. From The Dalles, Oregon, the 1993 bombing of the world trade center and numerous others, this isn’t new. We just have to be prepared, be watchful, but not let our civil liberties be trumped in the name of security. Sometimes a moderate course is the best course. Just my two cents.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s