Movie Review: Indiana Jones 4

May 23, 2008

I appreciate the fantasy that comes with movie making. I’m very good at suspending disbelief (it is a big reason why I love Star Wars), and I appreciate seeing the “hero” with no training win a sword fight or gun fight when duty calls.
That said, there were parts of Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull that even I couldn’t believe.
Fencing fights while straddling two jeeps … swinging Tarzan-style from jungle vines (and into a moving vehicle) … surviving three different drops down a waterfall … surviving an A-bomb blast in a refrigerator (thought that one was pretty cool) … aliens ….
All of this happened in the new Indy film, which felt a lot less like the previous three Indiana Jones installments, which were much more believable … even if they, too, were a little crazy.
But if you can get past the ridiculousness of some of the scenes — and heck, even if you can’t — then it’s possible to appreciate the new Indiana Jones.
All in all, I did … though I was able to look past the flaws.
The new film takes place about 20 years after the third (in the mid 1950s), and we meet a much older Indy as he’s been kidnapped by the Ruskies and taken to the same military storage facility that we saw at the end of Raiders of the Lost Ark, this time to help Cate Blanchett’s villainess find the remains of an alien she believes can lead to superhuman abilities (all in the effort to rule the world, of course).
Indy’s escape is dazzling, as is his introduction, and soon enough, he’s back teaching and he eventually meets a young 50s greaser named Mutt, played by Shia Lebeouf. A cleverly choreographed motorcycle chase later, and the two are on a plane to Peru to “follow the clues”.
Note, I’m skipping over a lot of plot filler here … the movie WAS two-plus hours long …
It’s there where the two find Mutt’s father-figure, a professor who’s gone crazy thanks to the crystal skull (an alien head, if you haven’t figured it out), and a familiar face from the first Indiana Jones film, Marion Ravenwood, played again by Karen Allen (who’s aged to the point where my wife couldn’t get over it … I thought she looked great considering it’s been nearly 30 years since the first).
The last half of the movie is a lot of “Watch Out!” and “Unbelievable!”, mixed in with some CGI and ancient puzzles. Don’t get me wrong, it’s fun … it just didn’t have the magic from Raiders of the Lost Ark or Last Crusade (I thought Temple of Doom had a silly ending, to be honest).
Despite his vine swinging and fencing, I like Shia’s character, and I have to admit, I’m becoming a fan of his. He was the only thing remotely worthwhile about Transformers, and he was great in Disturbia. And yes, I even remember him from his Even Stevens days.
Like I said, the movie is borderline ridiculous, but it’s a perfect summer movie, and it’s much better than similar movies like The Mummy or National Treasure. I’m not calling it a “must see,” but it’s definitely a “maybe go see.”

My grade: 6.5 out of 10.

Below: Again, we had fun with the movie review for this one in Friday’s Herald. Here’s what Page 1C in the Carolina section looked like (if you got a paper and got one of the copies where the printing was blurred, then I hope you appreciate what we tried to do).

Entry Filed under: Movie Reviews, Redesign. Tags: , , .

2 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Bob St Clair  |  May 23, 2008 at 8:47 pm

    You grade of 6.5 is in line with what we gave to movie.

    Would I tell others not to go see it? NEVER, but I would not encourage it either.

    Reply
  • 2. Al Roethlisberger  |  July 2, 2008 at 4:24 pm

    We really enjoyed this latest(last? …. we’ll see!) installment of the Indiana Jones franchise. Will Shia carry the torch forward? Who knows.

    My recollection of the first films was clouded by time, and I hadn’t realized that my children had never seen any of them. In fact, when I took my 13 year old daughter and 10 year old son to another movie some time back, I pointed out the ‘coming soon’ poster, and was surprised to hear both of them exclaim…. ‘Indiana WHO?’ Good grief, I had failed as a parent :)

    So, we embarked on an Indiana Jones cram session, watching all three prior films over a week before seeing the new one. And except for perhaps ‘The Last Crusade’, one thing was apparent, they didn’t quite hold up as well as my memory served. They weren’t bad of course, just not quite as slick and edge-of-the-seat entertaining as I recalled. I guess age does that.

    If I had to rate them, from best to worst:

    The Last Crusade
    Raiders of the Lost Ark
    …. and a distant third, The Temple of Doom

    And this wasn’t just my impression, as the kids were distinctly unimpressed with Temple and had to be prodded from falling asleep or otherwise losing interest, but seemed to really enjoy parts of Raiders, and pretty much all of Crusade. They also agreed with your review of Temple being just a bit too silly overall, and I concur.

    But putting the films in perspective chronologically and technologically, the films were probably as good as one can expect, and all-in-all we enjoyed our trip through the way-back machine.

    However, having the recent perspective of watching all three prior films within a week of seeing the new one, my family seemed to agree that the latest film was quite good, absolutely better than Temple and Raiders, and a good challenger for Crusade.

    I agree that some scenes like the jeep swashbuckling and never ending cable/vine swinging was a bit much, but then again the first films were full of similar antics if one recalls. Plus by definition, this “old timey adventure serial” throwback hearkens to all the great “unbelievable” treasure, jungle, and adventure films of the 50’s and 60’s. Hey, at least we had no herky-jerky Vishnu-esque stop motion monsters in these films! :)

    Looking past the truly unbelievable, I liked the core story, thought the effects were very good, and found the overall mood to be a reasonable reproduction of that ‘10yr old Saturday afternoon feel’ one got watching Jason, Tarzan, or some other film adventurer when he found that subterranean treasure trove guarded by a supernatural foe. If that was the goal, the film succeeded for me. I just wish there had been a bit ‘more’ to the finale. Like many films, it wrapped it all up in a neat bow just a bit too quickly.

    And as I mentioned in my WALL-E feedback, darn them for using modern controls on Shia’s ‘vintage’ Harley Davidson. That was a silly, and for any motorcycle fan glaring, oversight. But we’ll survive :)

    So I agree, 6ish stars.

    I recommended it to my friend and his kids, but that was certainly weighted by its lineage. If this film had been on its own, and not part of the Indiana Jones legacy, I probably would have ended up watching it as a rental like National Treasure.

    Al

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Required

Required, hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Billy Liggett



I am a 33-year-old newspaper editor and radio show host living in Sanford, North Carolina. I have been editor at the Sanford Herald since February, 2007, and I've been in newspapers since 1999. I married my college sweetheart Jennifer in 2003, and today, we're the proud parents of a little girl, Hayley Alexandra (born Oct. 3, 2009) plus an 8-year-old Jack Russell Terrier and year-old Labernese.

Download the radio show,
The Rant

Sept. 16 (Sara O'Leary)
Sept. 9
Sept. 2 (Carl Bryan)
Aug. 26
Aug. 12
Aug. 5(Bill Stone, Linda Higgins)
July 29 (Eddie Watkins)
July 22
July 15
June 17 (Anniversary show)
June 10 (Eddie Watkins)
June 3 (no guest)


Newspaper Design
Click here to see my NewsPageDesigner.com portfolio, which includes designs from the past four years.

RSS Twitter

Blogroll

Other Herald Blogs
• Community Editor Jonathan Owens
• Sports Editor Alex Podlogar
• Staff writer Caitlin Mullen
• Photographer Ashley Garner
• Sports writer Ryan Sarda
• Movie critic Neil Morris

Local Officials
• Lee County Sheriff Tracy Carter

Local Bloggers
Amy Burns
Anyone Hungry?
Danita Russell
E-Lee Dispatch
Emily Page
I am the Mama
Jamie Stamm
Joe Jon Bryant
Kim Pritt
Shannon Gurwitch

Organization Blogs
Carolina Trace Country Club
Central Carolina Jaycees
Lee County Republican Party blog
Sanford Area Chamber of Commerce Blog
Sanford Historic District forum
Stepping Stones blog

E-mail me at bliggett@sanfordherald.com if you'd like to be added

Links: Local government
The City of Sanford, North Carolina
The Sanford Area Chamber of Commerce
Lee County Government
Lee County Schools

Links: Personal favorites
The Sanford Herald
Front page of nearly every newspaper in U.S.
Movie reviews
USA Today's Pop Candy
Dallas Cowboys
Pearl Jam

Recent comments

Jamie Stamm on Hayley turns a month old today…
adpt1 on Animal Control editorial
Al Roethlisberger on Hayley turns a month old today…
David Wilsen on Note to Charter Cable: Get the…
jay on Noelle Marsh on SYTYCD

Movie reviews

Ratings 1 (bad) through 10 (perfect)
The Dark Knight (10)
Up (9.5)
Wall•E (9)
Superbad (9)
Cloverfield (9)
There Will Be Blood (8)
Juno (8)
Ratatouille (8)
Tropic Thunder (7.5)
The Hangover
The Simpsons Movie (7.5)
Pineapple Express (7)
U23D (7)
H. Potter, Phoenix (7)
Watchmen (6.5)
Atonement (6)
Sweeney Todd (6)
Indiana Jones 4 (5.5)
Charlie Wilson's War (5)
High Sch. Musical 2 (5)
Walk Hard (3)
Flawless (2)
Transformers (1)

CLICK HERE for my Rotten Tomatoes Journal

free html hit counter

Calendar

May 2008
S M T W T F S
« Apr   Jun »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Categories

Archives

Top Posts

Blog hits

  • 226,804 followers since June, 07

Disclaimer

The views expressed on this Web site are by no means meant to represent the views of The Sanford Herald or Paxton Media Group.


Feeds

Pages

Blogroll

Meta